DARK SECRETS
// MUSIC:
The death of a former boyfriend and
incriminating charges from former
backing musicians are clouds hanging
over Sheryl Crow's sunny career.
by JOEL SELVIN
San Francisco Chronicle
A black hood covered his face. He wore
a black skirt. His head was slumped
against a leather strap chained to the
headboard of the king-size bed in the
sparsely furnished living room.
Kevin Gilbert, 29, was dead. That much
his manager could see peering in at the
front door that morning last May.
The Los Angeles County coroner's
office sees four or five such deaths a
year - "autoerotic asphyxiation," caused
when people go one small step too far in
depriving their brains of oxygen while
they reach orgasm. It was a death
without dignity, a random fall through
the cracks of a secret life.
Gilbert was a musical prodigy from San
Mateo who could play any instrument;
colleagues invariably called him "the
most talented musician I ever met." To
the rest of the world, though, his only
real claim to fame lies in the credits to
"Tuesday Night Music Club," the 1993
debut album by Sheryl Crow.
"I saw something in Entertainment
magazine that said Kevin Gilbert, the
piano player on Sheryl Crow's record,
had died," said songwriter David
Baerwald, a member of the Tuesday
club of the album's name. He paused,
sadly shaking his head. "He hated that
Sheryl Crow record and that's all he's
going to be known for. The piano
player? Roll over, Kevin Gilbert."
When Gilbert first brought his girlfriend
Sheryl to informal Tuesday-night
songwriting sessions with his friends, he
played a pivotal role in shaping an $85
million megahit. For her, the album
brought three Grammys, stardom and an
industry buzz that makes her
forthcoming album one of the most
eagerly anticipated releases this fall. But
for him, it was hardly a triumph.
"I don't know if I can ever forgive her,"
he wrote in his journal. "I don't hate her
- I'm just soooo disappointed."
In a way it's a classic Hollywood tale:
Gifted boy artist meets girl artist,
mentors her to success and is left in the
dust - equal parts "Sunset Boulevard,"
"A Star Is Born," and "All About Eve."
By any measure, Gilbert's career was a
fitful tumble of brilliance and
happenstance, a series of near misses
and one hit that wasn't his. And his
Tuesday night cohorts describe Crow,
who refused to be interviewed for this
story, as a marginally talented singer
who exploited his skills and theirs in a
ruthless grab for success.
But this wasn't a movie, and so the real
story is inevitably messier and more
complex. As the circumstances of his
death suggest, Gilbert had a dark side, a
hidden face that made him an enigma to
his friends. There was a history of
anti-depressant use and a string of
journal entries registering acute
self-loathing and doubt.
BRIGHT BEGINNING
He had a promising start. As a teen-ager,
Gilbert was given the run of Sensa
Sound studio in Sunnyvale after hours;
there he recorded tracks with his
progressive rock group, Giraffe. In 1988
he won the U.S. and worldwide finals of
a talent contest run by the Yamaha
piano company. One of the judges, Pat
Leonard, a producer for Madonna,
invited Gilbert to make a record in Los
Angeles.
That album, "Toy Matinee," sold nearly
200,000 copies in 1991, thanks in part
to an MTV video featuring actress
Rosanna Arquette (whom Gilbert had
dated). Gilbert put together a road
version that included his then girlfriend
on background vocals and second
keyboard, Sheryl Crow.
Making that album, at age 21, Gilbert
met another record producer, Bill
Bottrell, who became a kind of father
figure. Bottrell brought him to sessions
for Madonna and Michael Jackson;
before long, Gilbert had sublet the space
adjacent to Bottrell's Pasadena studio,
Toad Hall. From there he set about
recording his solo debut.
Drawing on all his perfectionist instincts,
along with his ingrained self-doubts,
Gilbert didn't just work on his record; he
suffered over it, recording and
rerecording, polishing, tweaking,
rethinking, redoing.
"It was a long process," said Bottrell,
who used to hear Gilbert thumping away
through the common wall. "He sat over
there endless nights."
In August 1992, Bottrell convened a
gathering of Gilbert and other musicians
at Toad Hall with the simple agenda of
collaborating for the fun of it every
Tuesday night. "We were all good, not
to be immodest," Baerwald said. "We
were also all cynical, embittered by the
process of pop music. We were trying to
find some joy in music again."
A party atmosphere predominated. "Bill
would sift through (the music) the next
morning while we were all nursing
hangovers," drummer Brian MacLeod
recalled. Then Bottrell introduced a
project he thought might force a little
focus onto the freewheeling, chaotic
sessions.
Crow had finished an album for A&M
Records, but despite the $500,000 spent
on it, nobody at the label was thrilled
with the results. Hoping for a quick fix,
A&M hired Gilbert to remix the album,
which was, in the immutable illogic of
the record industry, already scheduled
for release. Crow's manager asked
Bottrell to step in as well.
On Crow's first Tuesday night with the
club, Baerwald showed up with musical
sidekick David Ricketts (from the 1986
David and David album), both of them
high on LSD, with the first verse already
written to a song, "Leaving Las Vegas."
Baerwald picked up a guitar, Ricketts
the bass, and the band fell together to
pick up where it had left off.
"Baerwald couldn't function," Bottrell
said. "Sheryl started to get drunk. I was
looking for that moment when the good
take would happen."
For most of that year, Bottrell and his
Tuesday crew - now working all week
long - scrupulously fashioned and
reshaped Crow's album. Because
everything was a collaboration,
songwriting credits were equally shared.
"Everybody was equal," Baerwald said,
"except Sheryl. She wasn't one of us.
We helped her make a record."
Gilbert's name wound up on seven of
the 11 songs; he sang and played
keyboards, guitar, bass and drums.
His relationship with Crow was kept
separate and even a secret from the
group. "I'd see long conversations in the
parking lot," Baerwald said.
"Kevin challenged her," MacLeod said.
"He was trying to get her to be honest
and sing from her heart."
Unsure of herself, professionally in over
her head, Crow went home with Gilbert
after sessions and listened to him rant
about the industry's failings. "She had
Kevin filling her with doubts," Bottrell
said.
When he wasn't with Crow or the club,
Gilbert struggled with his solo album,
playing most of the instruments on his
supple but powerful pop-rock tracks -
polished productions that showed the
gleam of countless studio hours. A
proposed deal with a major label fell
apart, so he made do with a tiny custom
label.
After nearly a year of working together,
all for one and one for all, the Tuesday
Night musicians were shocked to learn
they didn't figure into Crow's plans.
Bottrell got the news when he met her to
hand over the finished master in a
Sunset Strip coffee shop. Although there
had been much talk of hitting the road
together to promote the record - bassist
Dan Schwartz even bought a new bass
for the tour - "she essentially told me to
get lost," Bottrell said.
"I add Sheryl Crow to a long list of
people in Hollywood who told me they
were my friend until they got what they
wanted from me," Schwartz said.
LIFE FALLING APART
As Crow's relationship with Gilbert
deteriorated - apparently she turned her
attentions to an executive at the record
label, Baerwald said - an increasingly
bitter Gilbert threw himself deeper into
his own album.
"I think I'm a tinge jealous over her
upcoming release," he wrote in his
journal. "It's probably going to be huge,
so I have to prepare myself mentally for
that. If she gets what she wants after
behaving this way, she'll be absolutely
intolerable."
For Gilbert, the final straw came when
Crow sang "Leaving Las Vegas" on the
David Letterman show. Afterward,
when Letterman asked her if the song
was autobiographical, a flustered Crow
blurted out, "Yes."
"I've never been to Las Vegas,"
continued Crow, who nobody
remembers having contributed greatly to
the writing of the song. "I wrote it about
Los Angeles. It's really metaphorical."
The next day, she and Gilbert exchanged
angry words over the phone. He wasn't
the only one furious. Author John
O'Brien, who wrote the novel that
inspired both Baerwald's early song
lyrics and the movie starring Nicolas
Cage, was still grumbling about Crow's
gaffe to his literary agent on the day he
blew his brains out, a scant few weeks
before the movie deal was complete.
As Crow's album soared on the charts
(her nod to Gilbert in the liner notes
says, "I owe you big for two years of
musical and emotional support.
Thanks"), Gilbert's solo album, a
masterful but underpromoted effort
titled "Thud," disappeared almost
immediately on release. At the same
time, ironically, a tape he recorded for
the Led Zeppelin tribute album, dropped
from the disc at the last minute,
exploded on Los Angeles radio, leaving
his label ineptly scrambling to capitalize.
Despite its new prominence, the
Tuesday Night Music Club never could
quite regroup. The members did play
one guest appearance with Crow at an
out-of-town club, but the record
company made it clear they would not
be included in the more prestigious
Hollywood show.
Gilbert threw himself into other projects:
helping Baerwald produce a solo album
by Susanna Hoffs of the Bangles,
working with Bottrell on an album by
Linda Perry of 4 Non Blonds (the
Tuesday Night gang dubbed her "the
anti-Sheryl"), writing and recording
scores for TV shows under a
pseudonym. He even produced a movie
soundtrack song for which Crow sang
vocals - a version of Steve Miller's "The
Joker" - although they were never in the
studio at the same time.
In November 1994, Gilbert met
playwright Cintra Wilson at a party in
San Francisco; two months later she
moved to Los Angeles to live with him.
"He was massively depressed over the
whole Sheryl debacle," Wilson said. "I
was a basket case. We were perfect for
each other."
Despite the tension with Crow, most of
the Tuesday Night Music Club attended
the Grammy Awards in March 1995. To
show irreverence, Wilson rented
19th-century funeral regalia for Gilbert
and her to wear: a morning coat and top
hat for him, ostrich plumes and a bustle
for her. Crow sat in the row in front of
them. "They were not on good terms,"
Wilson. "She was tensely gracious. It
was a furtive, tense, real glitzy night."
Crow picked up three awards, including
Record of the Year for "All I Wanna
Do," a Tuesday Night instrumental with
lyrics borrowed from verses in a
little-known volume by a poet in
Vermont. A week later, Gilbert was still
wearing his Grammy medallion around
his neck like a badge of valor.
From there, he set out to recapture the
creative anarchy he felt was the
authentic legacy of the club. He and
MacLeod produced some startling
recordings, far removed from anything
either of them had ever done.
They were scary, dense, pop-industrial
recordings, with Gilbert whispering
ominous, almost threatening processed
vocals. "They gave me nightmares,"
Bottrell said. Gilbert envisioned a new
band, Kaviar, clad in fetish rubber gear.
He pulled other musicians into the plan.
At the same time, Gilbert could toss off
simple, beautiful, sentimental tunes. In
Baerwald's last memory of Gilbert, the
pianist was noodling around on the
keyboard, plaintively singing Randy
Newman's "Marie." Baerwald had
briefly dozed off. "I woke up crying," he
said.
Bottrell, who played perhaps the largest
role in Gilbert's career, doesn't think he
ever really knew him. "There were
tremendous areas of his life I was not
privy to," he said. "There were motives
I could never quite figure out."
But Bottrell's wife, Elizabeth,
remembers sensing a powerful mood of
peace and reconciliation in a phone
conversation with Gilbert the afternoon
before he died. They talked about
attending an industry dinner together;
Gilbert kidded her about wearing rubber.
They never spoke again.
One afternoon this summer, several
hundred of Gilbert's friends and
associates gathered for a memorial
service at the Bottrells' Glendale home.
Wilson, dressed white, sat next to
MacLeod as Crow walked up to say
hello. "I barked at her," Wilson recalled.
Wilson knew the titles of the album's
songs well enough. "Run, baby, run,"
she yelped at Crow, who fled in tears.
Although Crow is reluctant to discuss
Gilbert, she has been openly vocal in
interviews about the rift over the album
with the Tuesday Night Music Club.
"There were guys in the group who
were feeling bitter about the record
doing so well," she recently told
Billboard magazine. "Maybe I should
have called it something else."
On Tuesday, she will release her
follow-up album, called - not
insignificantly, perhaps even defiantly -
"Sheryl Crow." Clearly, this singer
wants to prove that she's an act and a
talent all her own - not the
smoke-and-mirrors creation of a savvy,
multitalented backup band.
She did mention Gilbert to a Dutch
journalist last month. "I wasn't surprised
by his death," Crow told Edwin
Ammerlaan of Orr Magazine. "Kevin
was one of the most self-destructive
people I've ever met. I don't want to go
into this too much, but it wasn't a nice
story."